Joint Ventures Antitrust Primer; Case Study -- When Restraints on JV Members are Lawful but Price-Confidentiality Requirements Imposed on the JV's Customer Prevent Comparison of Prices

05 Mar , 2024

To register for the upcoming live webinar, please Click Here

The purpose of this course is to provide a primer about joint ventures.  First, what they are and why they formed.  Next, the course will explain the antitrust implications of joint ventures, via examination of the relevant statutes, case law and agency guidelines.   The course will focus on restraints imposed collectively on the venture members - - most importantly, what attributes make them illegal or not. 

The course then turns to a previously published examination of a series of joint ventures: Wall Street syndicates for private underwritings in excess of $100 million. The course notes that a small oligopoly of commercial and investment banks dominates the arranging and underwriting of loans and bonds for publicly traded companies, and that each underwriting is performed by a syndicate that constitutes a joint venture of competitors.  Further, that each syndicate requires the borrower to agree not to disclose the syndicate’s fee, an obligation that requires not just violation of the securities laws, but constitutes a price-related restraint of each joint venture at issue.  The course concludes that the series of price-related restraints compelling price confidentiality impacts the market for the fees in question by preventing customers to compare them, or show them to competitors in fee negotiations.

A quote of interest from the underlying Article, explained in more detail during the seminar: 

“One leading securities law expert has opined that ‘the failure to file these agreements suggests that it is the ‘custom and practice’ of Wall Street banks to violate the securities laws by directing customers to keep documents relating to their fees confidential”. 

Also, on reviewing the article, the authors of a 2020 Article , “Collusion in Markets with Syndication,” commented that “[t]his is great. It seems like the fees are known internally through the network of banks, so they can monitor compliance with the collusive agreement, but not known externally, so it is hard for a new entrant to figure out the best way to undercut the collusive agreement.”

 

To register for the upcoming live webinar, please Click Here

More Webcasts

Billing Brilliance: ...

Unrecorded time, vague entries, and end-of-month write-offs cost firms significant revenue. This pra...

The New Patent Wars:...

Artificial intelligence is reshaping the strategy and economics of patent litigation, from locating ...

Corporate Counsel’...

Class action litigation continues to expand in both number of filings and monetary exposure, with se...

Winning Military Pay...

I was wrongfully separated from the military and I will get no military pay and disability retiremen...

How to Respond to Sh...

Adverse and derogatory information often has devastating effects on a contractor's ability to win co...

Restoring Second Rig...

During this course you will learn about the Federal Firearm Rights Restoration program and the Feder...

When the Court Uses ...

Most lawyers are aware of the high-profile cases in which attorneys were sanctioned or otherwise dis...

Correcting Military ...

Incorrect military records prevent active duty and reserve Soldiers, Airmen, Guardians, Marines, Sai...

AI Use in Healthcare...

This presentation aims to explore various models and cases of artificial intelligence use in healthc...

Modern Cross-Examina...

Attendees will learn how to effectively cross-examine witnesses at trial.  The conventional wis...